Yellow evening primrose is an erect forb with yellow, 4-parted flowers that only open in the morning. Petals are 5-12mm long, floral tube 4-angled, funnel shaped, half as long as the ovary, and covered in small hairs. Stigma are broad and shield-shaped. Its fruits are linear, roundly 4-angled, 1.5-3cm long, and are covered with white or gray hairs. Its leaves are alternate, simple, numerous, oblong to linear to inversely lance-shaped, 2-6cm long x 7mm wide with very small, remote, sharp teeth.
It can be distinguished from other Oenothera species by its broad and shield-shaped stigma not having 4 linear lobes.