American shoreweed is an emergent aquatic forb with an inflorescence that is unisexual, basal, and in groups of 3, sepals are 2.5-4mm long and lanceolate. Its fruits are cylindric achenes, 2mm long and half as wide. Its leaves are linear, terete, glabrous, and up to 5cm.
It can be distinguished from other small, linear-leaved aquatics simply by its round leaves, which only have one vein. Other small linear-leaved aquatic species have either bulbous leaf bases (Isoetes), triangular leaves (Eriocaulon), flat leaves (Juncus pelocarpus, Sagittaria and Valisneria) or stolons connecting clumps (Ranunculus flammula).