Handsome sedge is a graminoid, 30-70cm tall, with a gynecandrous terminal spike, 2-4 lateral spikes, 1 per node, well separated, drooping at maturity, most are pistillate except for 1-2 male flowers at base of each. Its perigynia are beakless, green, copiously red dotted, 2-ribbed with 7-12 fine veins on each face, loosely enveloping the achene, ovoid-ellipsoid, membranous, base with short stipe, apex narrowing to abrupt beak, and glabrous, achenes are substipitate. Basal sheaths are maroon, bladeless, pubescent, sometimes glabrous, others grading from maroon to green on back, white-hyaline, red dotted, and pilose on front. Blades are flat, 3-7mm wide, glabrous on adaxial surface, pilose on abaxial surface and margins.
It is most similar to Carex davisii, which has staminate flowers at the base of only the terminal spikelet, and pistillate scales with distinct prolonged awns that equal or exceed the perigynia.